Evaluation process
Reviewer Recommendations and Editorial Decisions
Decision Matrix
|
Reviewer 1 |
Reviewer 2 |
Reviewer 3 |
Editor’s Decision |
Post-Correction Re-Evaluation |
|
AF |
AF |
--- |
AF |
--- |
|
AF |
AF/SR/MIN |
--- |
AF |
--- |
|
AF |
AF/SR/MAJ |
--- |
AF/SR |
Required |
|
AF |
AD |
AD |
AD |
--- |
|
AF |
AD |
AF |
AF |
--- |
|
AF/SR/MIN |
AF/SR/MIN |
--- |
AF |
--- |
|
AF/SR/MIN |
AF/SR/MAJ |
--- |
AF/SR |
Required |
|
AF/SR/MIN |
AD |
AD |
AD |
--- |
|
AF/SR/MIN |
AD |
AF |
AF |
--- |
|
AF/SR/MAJ |
AF/SR/MAJ |
--- |
AF/SR |
Required |
|
AF/SR/MAJ |
AD |
--- |
AD |
--- |
Key:
- AF: Favorable Opinion
- AD: Unfavorable Opinion
- AF/SR/MIN: Favorable Opinion with Minor Revisions
- AF/SR/MAJ: Favorable Opinion with Major Revisions
Important Notes
- Articles recommended for AF/SR/MIN require author revisions before acceptance.
- Only manuscripts meeting high-quality standards post-revisions proceed to publication.
